Science: possible → likely → very likely → certain. “This result makes the explanation likely” differs from “This result proves it is certain.”
02 · The classroom routine
Teach the move
Prepare · 5 minutes
Choose words that vary along a meaningful dimension, not just a list of synonyms.
1
Set a dimension such as certainty or intensity.
2
Pairs place words along a line and discuss disputed positions.
3
Test each word in the same sentence to hear the change in meaning.
4
Choose the word that best fits the available evidence.
EAL upgrade
Remove the continuum and ask learners to justify their degree of certainty.
Keep the subject challenge. Offer one model, visual or language prompt where needed, then check a fresh independent response.
03 · A plan for the next lesson
Try it tomorrow
Prepare one task
Choose words that vary along a meaningful dimension, not just a list of synonyms.
Model and rehearse
Set a dimension such as certainty or intensity. Pairs place words along a line and discuss disputed positions.
Collect evidence
Give limited evidence and ask learners to reject an overconfident wording.
Next time
Remove the continuum and ask learners to justify their degree of certainty.
What to look for
Give limited evidence and ask learners to reject an overconfident wording.
04 · Words you can use
Teacher language
Adapt these prompts to the task and your learners.
Launch
Our purpose is: Choose vocabulary that expresses the intended degree or relationship.
Probe the thinking
Which detail supports your explanation? Show me how you know.
Check independently
Try the new case on your own. Show the detail or reasoning that supports your answer.
Hand over
Which support do you still need, and which part can you now do independently?
05 · Keep the move, change the context
Across subjects
Transfer 1
Humanities: rank language of certainty in competing interpretations.
Transfer 2
Maths: compare approximate, close and exact in statements about measurement.
Adjust language support
Use a small word bank, visuals and partner rehearsal when needed. Extend with precise explanations and qualifications. Judge the support from the response to this task.
Keep the strategy. Change the subject.
Four classroom examples
Use the task, response and evidence check as a starting point for your curriculum.
Science
Set up the task
Arrange possible, likely and certain when discussing whether a material will conduct electricity before testing it.
Possible student response
It is likely to conduct because it is a metal, but we need the test result to support the claim.
Check the learning
Ask whether the evidence warrants the degree of certainty.
Humanities
Set up the task
Place source claims along a continuum from possible to strongly supported.
Possible student response
The poster was probably intended to persuade, but its effect on viewers is uncertain.
Check the learning
Separate confidence about purpose from confidence about audience response.
English
Set up the task
Compare suggests, indicates and proves when interpreting a character’s pause.
Possible student response
The pause may suggest uncertainty; it does not prove the character is afraid.
Check the learning
Ask what additional context would strengthen the interpretation.
Maths
Set up the task
Use impossible, unlikely, equally likely, likely and certain with a bag containing three red and one blue counter.
Possible student response
Red is more likely than blue, but red is not certain because a blue counter remains possible.
Check the learning
Check the probability against the actual outcomes in the bag.