1Discuss what the question asks and what the opening should establish
2Provide one opening that contains no complete answer
3Learners add evidence and an explanation
4Compare endings and revise the opening if it no longer fits
Worked classroom example
History: “One reason the protest gained support was…” Learners must name a reason and explain how the evidence supports it.
A model to discuss and adapt to your class.
02 · The classroom routine
Teach the move
Prepare · 5 minutes
Write a first sentence that establishes the topic and leaves the reasoning to the learner.
1
Discuss what the question asks and what the opening should establish.
2
Provide one opening that contains no complete answer.
3
Learners add evidence and an explanation.
4
Compare endings and revise the opening if it no longer fits.
EAL upgrade
Offer two possible openings, then ask learners to compose their own.
Keep the subject challenge. Offer one model, visual or language prompt where needed, then check a fresh independent response.
03 · A plan for the next lesson
Try it tomorrow
Prepare one task
Write a first sentence that establishes the topic and leaves the reasoning to the learner.
Model and rehearse
Discuss what the question asks and what the opening should establish. Provide one opening that contains no complete answer.
Collect evidence
Can the learner continue with relevant evidence rather than a list of unrelated facts?
Next time
Offer two possible openings, then ask learners to compose their own.
What to look for
Can the learner continue with relevant evidence rather than a list of unrelated facts?
04 · Words you can use
Teacher language
Adapt these prompts to the task and your learners.
Launch
Our purpose is: Give learners a route into writing while leaving the reasoning to them.
Probe the thinking
Which detail supports your explanation? Show me how you know.
Check independently
Try the new case on your own. Show the detail or reasoning that supports your answer.
Hand over
Which support do you still need, and which part can you now do independently?
05 · Keep the move, change the context
Across subjects
Transfer 1
Science: “The results show a relationship between…”
Transfer 2
Maths: “These two methods give the same result because…”
Adjust language support
Use a small word bank, visuals and partner rehearsal when needed. Extend with precise explanations and qualifications. Judge the support from the response to this task.
Keep the strategy. Change the subject.
Four classroom examples
Science
Set up the task
Offer “The results show a relationship between…” and ask learners to continue from a labelled table.
Possible student response
The results show a relationship between temperature and evaporation rate: the warmer sample lost more water over the same time.
Check the learning
Check the trend against the data and distinguish correlation from a proved mechanism.
Humanities
Set up the task
Offer “One reason the protest gained support was…” and provide evidence about a new tax.
Possible student response
One reason the protest gained support was the new tax, which increased costs for affected households.
Check the learning
Ask learners to use the actual source evidence and qualify the scope of the claim.
English
Set up the task
Offer “The description makes the setting seem…” and ask for quotation and interpretation.
Possible student response
The description makes the setting seem neglected because the broken windows and dust suggest it has not been cared for.
Check the learning
Check that the opening leaves the learner to choose and explain the evidence.
Maths
Set up the task
Offer “These fractions can be compared by…” without completing the method.
Possible student response
These fractions can be compared by rewriting them with a common denominator, so the parts are equally sized.
Check the learning
Give new fractions and ask learners to continue with their own calculation.